This site uses cookies.

Legal Mind Case and Commentary No 10: Who Knows Best? the Judge or the Expert? - Dr Hugh Koch & Dr Jacquie Hetherton, Hugh Koch Associates

18/09/16. The judge weighs the arguments set before him and ensures that pertinent issues have been addressed. He is aided by barristers, lawyers and experts who should have considered all relevant matters, in a logical way. Despite the adversarial and at times selective approach of the two sides, all matters of relevance should be laid before the judge. This case illustrates what can happen when this has not occurred.

Case: Burne v. A (2006 CA WL 316092)

The case of Burne v. A was heard in the Court of Appeal in December 2005, and involved a six-year-old with a ventricular shunt who developed sickness at school. The GP misdiagnosed an infection rather than a blocked shunt. As a result, he developed permanent neurological damage. The GP experts called by both sides agreed it was acceptable to ask open-ended questions. The judge disagreed and found the GP in breach of his duty of care to A for not asking closed-ended questions. The judge found that...

Image ©iStockphoto.com/liveostockimages

Read more (PIBULJ subscribers only)...

All information on this site was believed to be correct by the relevant authors at the time of writing. All content is for information purposes only and is not intended as legal advice. No liability is accepted by either the publisher or the author(s) for any errors or omissions (whether negligent or not) that it may contain. 

The opinions expressed in the articles are the authors' own, not those of Law Brief Publishing Ltd, and are not necessarily commensurate with general legal or medico-legal expert consensus of opinion and/or literature. Any medical content is not exhaustive but at a level for the non-medical reader to understand. 

Professional advice should always be obtained before applying any information to particular circumstances.

Excerpts from judgments and statutes are Crown copyright. Any Crown Copyright material is reproduced with the permission of the Controller of OPSI and the Queen’s Printer for Scotland under the Open Government Licence.